11 May, 2009

Can I Give Sri Lankan Army the Benefit of the Doubt?

I can’t watch pictures of dead children any more, without making me chock and feeling utterly helpless. I don’t know what it is to a parent to lose a child, but I know what it is to have a child. And I can’t possibly imagine how a parent could bear lost of a child.

1000 people dead one say, 2000 people dead say others. Just numbers, anonymous people, rounded up to last digits for our convenience. But they all are people with faces, legs and hopes, some are parents to a child like our parents and some child to a parent like our children.

As a citizen in a democratic country, I have a moral and civil responsibility to what our army is doing. If Sri Lankan Army shelled on those civilians, they should burn in hell, we all should burn in hell, because we know better, because we have other options. We drag this war more than a quarter century. I know every single day it drag further, it only bring suffering to everyone, but we could wait couple of more days, couple of more weeks, if needed couple of more months. We don’t have to risk large number of civilians. We shouldn’t have risk children. There are other options. There are better options.

But at this moment, I’m willing to accept government’s version of the story and give benefit of the doubt to Sri Lankan Army, only because LTTE does not have any military power that they can use for a victory or even for survival against Sri Lankan military, but they still don’t want to surrender, because they have a single card left, which they have been using quite vigorously and successfully. Civilians. They keep on holding thousands of civilians that they collected on their retreat, not to keep as pets, or as hotel guests, but for their military use, just like bullets, buckets and such other objects that they may dispose for their tactical benefit. And Canadian and British LTTE members propagate civilian death to the maximum military benefit of LTTE. More civilians die, more children die, more advantage they collect. Attract enemy fire on to civilians or deliberately killing civilians for propaganda, always has been fully working tactic for LTTE. In the absent of military power, I don’t think LTTE is sitting around a table playing cards with each other smoking cigars, or drinking tea or reading comic books. They are working on the only tactic left for them to reach their goal – a ceasefire. That is kill civilians, thousands by thousands, until so call “international community” forces government to go to a truce. It is brutal tactic. But it is a working tactic. It is bloody working tactic.

4 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I don't know, and for the most part, I really don't care. It's hard to feel sorry for them when I see all these LTTE rallies. Why should we refrain from doing what they already accuse us of doing. What difference does it make if we do it or not.

These so called hostages willingly went to live with the LTTE. I'm sure all of them (until now) have supported the Tamil Tigers and "yearned" with them for Eelam. As far as I'm concerned, these people are expendable to win this war. We should try to minimise civilian deaths, but not our soldiers should not risk their lives to save our enemies. I'm ready to accept this cost and any repurcussions.

By the time the international wheels would start turning, we would have already won the war.

May 14, 2009 11:32 AM  
Blogger Sam said...

I don’t think, they (so call hostages) had any other choice. Even they went with LTTE willingly; we have a responsibility to ourselves, not to international community, whom by the way, are the main reason for death of those civilians. Even if you don’t care about civilians, we have a military responsibility to take them out of the control of LTTE. Those civilians, LTTE are using as bargain chips (not as a human shield by the way) in the absence of whatsoever significant military power, are the only strength LTTE have to stop the Army offensive. I guess they may prefer Army killing them, but if not, LTTE will do it themselves behalf, according to the time table of Canadians and are likes.

I think the cost is brutally high. But if that is what it take for the next generations to live in peace, I would go to a corner and cry until all this end.

May 14, 2009 11:29 PM  
Blogger Liberal Lanka said...

Don't let your love for the country fool you. LTTE kill civilians who try to escape. But thinking they shell their own human shield when both are trapped into a 2 km strip is foolish. At least the anon has been honest here.

Just think sam, people who survived are gonna come out someday, if we are going to insist egoistically that no civilians were killed by our fire where are we pushing them into?

And no SL army should not burn in hell, they were not the elitists responsible for this mess in the first place and they don't fight this for fun. they are humans too and they have children of their own too. They can't risk their lives all the time just to save civilians.

Gees, you are going to believe the government? The government kept on insisting that there were only 60,000 civilians in the free fire zone and just in two days over a 100,000 crossed over. still believe them?

May 14, 2009 11:50 PM  
Blogger Sam said...

LL,
I don’t pretend to be the most honest man in the world, I’m far from that. I don’t rule out “love for the country” or if not “hate for LTTE at this stage”. Not caring for civilians and deliberately killing civilians is two deferent things. These are the reasoning behind my conclusion. (I’m forced to come to my own conclusion, because I don’t trust this government or any government)

What LTTE want? a ceasefire.
What powers they have to demand a ceasefire? No military power. No political power. All they have is those civilians they herd alone with them. I do not buy the human-shield argument. One needs a shield, only if they have capacity to go offensive. LTTE may brutal. But they are not stupid. How long one can shield behind just civilians without offensive or defensive power?
How one achieves a ceasefire using civilians? Create drama. Not just any drama, but tragedy.

Therefore, it is LTTE’s best interest to see those people dead and it is their only option. Now, Army have a military responsibility, (forget about moral part) to spoil the enemies working tactics. All good solders may not go to hell, but it is possible for an Army to go to hell.

May 15, 2009 7:30 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home